Butterfinger Cake

This butterfinger cake recipe is the best cake ever, I make it all the time.

(4.5, 190) 83% would make again
Yield: 12 Servings

Cuisine: American   Main Ingredient: Cake


Add My Review
I make this all the time using yellow cake mix instead, I also omit the chocolate syrup so it's not overly sweet. My husband and kids love it! I have to admit, not the healthiest but it's such an amazing guilty pleasure :)
taintedhalo26 , 10m ago

kablueys , 1y ago

Best cake I've made
shiannenacol , 1y ago

My son asked me to make this for him a couple of years ago for his birthday. Every year this is what he wants for his birthday. This is a very very sweet cake - but a BIG hit!
bakerette , 1y ago

I made this, but changed a few things the second time around: I used salted caramel ice cream topping (if you can't find salted caramel topping, just buy caramel ice cream topping and add sea salt to taste); eliminated the chocolate syrup and used homemade chocolate Ganache; and made my own unsweetened whipped cream. I found this balanced out the flavors more and wasn't overly sweet. Everyone loved it!!
bakingdiva57 , 1y ago

This cake is good but very sweet. I made it once and only at 1 piece and the rest my bf took to work for the guys to eat. Tastes good but is just way too much. I wouldn't make this cake again.
britt1225 , 2y ago

Great cake it was very moist. This was very rich and my whole family liked it.
gpecore88 , 2y ago

Love love love
stacystutler_lovingood , 2y ago

Made this for my daughter and her friends at college. Was a big hit! Used dark chocolate cake and snickers. Now need to make a other one for the kids at home.
new5man , 2y ago

this cake is so amazing and super easy to tweak with any other candy!
allysonpickles , 2y ago

mistysmith1 , 2y ago

lov1234 , 2y ago

This is so easy to make and tastes delicious I love love love chocolate so this took my taste buds to another level
andrearod10 , 2y ago

This is a cake that you can change the candy bar depending on your preference and it will taste just as good. Personally, I love it as a Take 5 cake. They are more difficult to smash than Butterfingers, but they are DELICIOUS!!!
audpaulkat13 , 2y ago

It definitely was not something i cared for but everyone else that ate it loved it. I might make it again for them.
mpercoco , 3y ago

Yummmmm! Made for my fiancé's birthday and the whole gang loved it. Used 4 butterfingers because someone in the house ate one. I don't think it was overly sweet, I think it was just perfect. can eat a
candicesflowers , 3y ago

I use the cheap brand of devils food cake, and 1 king size butter finger, my family loves it!
nmiller111709 , 3y ago

Delicious!!! Made it for friends and they loved it. I used evaporated milk instead of sweetened condensed milk by mistake but it still turned out tasty and moist. I also only used 2 candy bars since I didn't want it to be overly sweet/crunchy. Will definitely make this again!!
mandana , 3y ago

This cake is delicious! It's extremely sweet but I've still made it a few times. The family loves it!
1chefarmiller , 3y ago

    Add unlimited recipes. Remove ads. Custom folders. Find recipes for your diet. Try BigOven Pro Free