Reviews for Brown Bag Apple Pie | BigOven

Brown Bag Apple Pie

An old family favorite apple pie with a crumb topping.

(4.9, 40) 90% would make again

1732 people marked it a Favorite, 1072 people marked it a Try

Yield: 6 Ready in 45 minutes

Cuisine: American   Main Ingredient: Apples

Reviews

Add My Review
Awesome-awesome! Made for Thanksgiving and got RAVE reviews! Definately a keeper and is now a requested MUST for next year! Used 1 Braeburn, 1.5 Granny Smith, 1 Fuji and 1 Pink Lady. Drool!!!!!
Jboccuzzio , 2 years ago
frytator , 2 years ago
Great, easy recipe. We call this the "Apple Crisp" pie, because it tastes just like old fashioned apple crisp. We plan to make again for Thanksgiving.
GeoffH24 , 2 years ago
I had my doubts about a paper bag in my oven....but it was soooo worth it!! YUM!!
Kathee , 2 years ago
The first and ONLY apple pie I have ever made! I changed it so it is Gluten Free for my celiacs. I just used Gluten free Bisquik :) So easy, fast, and really good!
janeblank , 3 years ago
One thing i did differently was I took an apple and sliced and peeled it. I took the topping and coated the apple slices. Then lay them around the edge and in the center and Bake like the rest on the directions. Just makes it pretty.
Mdeanddjo , 3 years ago
YUM! made with a smidge less sugar and it turned out great!
Skippypipper , 3 years ago
I have made this twice. It is awesome! I also made it for my friends at work, and they loved it. Very easy, not too many ingredients, and looks beautiful when finished!
amyandrus , 3 years ago
It was a smash!!!!!! The brown paper bag made it cook perfectly but I did throw it back in for a second for a more golden brown crust on top!
InFaithNotArms , 3 years ago
It came out perfect! It was a hit!
rrruis , 3 years ago
Very easy and very good apple pie. Try lime juice instead of lemon and fuji apples.
Avikemyr , 3 years ago
This pie is delicious and very easy. I took it out of the bag for about 5 min at the end of baking to crisp the topping.
Azile4 , 3 years ago
Amazing and easy
Abbysullivan , 4 years ago
Absolutely delicious. My husband said "THAT was really good" after he ate his piece and he doesn't give compliments away easily on food! I was a little concerned about the brown bag in the oven but it worked out fine. Can't wait to make this again!!
Jamiefaber , 4 years ago
I make this every chance I get for the holidays or even parties. It's an outstanding recipe. I don't always have a brown bag on hand so I've had to put foil around the edges of the crust after about 40mins to keep it from burning.
matt_sawyers , 4 years ago
I have made this apple pie at home at a dinner party before and it is DELICIOUS, all my guests LOVED it!
CambridgeChef101 , 4 years ago
Amazing! Medal awarded...
jeremyhendricks , 5 years ago
Great pie, easy to make. At the end of the evening the only thing left was the bottom of the pan...
awayteam , 5 years ago
LindaAndJack , 8 years ago
[I posted this recipe.]
LauriePerkins , 9 years ago
Add unlimited recipes. Organize in custom folders. Find recipes for your diet. Try BigOven Pro Free