Ready in 30 minutes
This cream of mushroom soup recipe is so much better than the canned, condensed version. It's worth the effort to make it from scratch.
"This is a great jumping off point for mushroom soup! I added a couple small diced red potatoes because I didn't have a full pound of mushrooms. I also added a little onion and minced garlic. I blended about 3/4 of the soup before adding milk. Since I didn't have cream I used Vitamin D milk and a little sour cream. We loved it. Thank you!"- Mollymcferren
1,098 people want to try | 1,923 have favorited
Top-ranked recipe named "Cream Of Mushroom Soup"
Wash mushrooms and chop coarsely.Heat the butter in a 3 quart saucepan. Saute the mushrooms about 5 minutes. Sprinkle the flour over to coat. Add the broth gradually, stirring constantly. Add the parsley and sherry. Bring to a boil. Remove from the heat and stir in the cream. (You may whirl in a blender at this point for a smoother texture, Some prefer just to leave as is).
This is great when your feeling a bit "down" and want some warm "comfort food".
BigOven makes mealtime easy!
You may also enjoy:
cuties 4 weeks agoLoved it will be making it again
kelik 1 month agoTruly better than canned and easily adaptable to gluten-free.
Queendragon 10 months agoVery good tasty recipe. I substituted the cream with milk to make the soup lower in calories.
Susanisham 10 months agoI cooked the flour well with the mushrooms, helps with the consistency, I also added sweet onion with the mushroom sauté. Pepper, & small amount of worcestershire sauce really brings a nice flavor.
ewtotel 1 year agoHow much sherry is everyone using? I used 1/4 cup... Seemed about right. Tastes AWESOME! I absolutely love this soup!
TimKoster 1 year ago
Cookin4younme 1 year agoDo not wash the mushrooms, clean with a damp sponge or paper towel... Washing will add extra water to your soup.
rsearer 1 year agoI screwed up and forgot to buy chicken broth, so I used beef broth instead, recipe still turned out delicious. Can't wait to try again the correct way!
Mamacone01 1 year agoAmazing taste, the whole family loved it and we've made it multiple times since. Good and easy but tastes like you've been cooking it for hours.
Elizabethd002 1 year agoI did not enjoy the soup. My boyfriend did however. Something about the taste and the flour. I did not use sherry. I will try again, possibly my error. I might add sour cream, more mushrooms, and better stock. But I like a lot of the recipes posted by this chef. Thanks.
amandavega 1 year agoExcellent and easy to make
bigduke06 2 years agoIt was a little thin for my liking. The second time I made it I mixed some of the mushroom liquid with a couple of tablespoons of flour and then added it back in with the cream, then let it simmer for bit. Delicious!!!!
Elow88 2 years agoMy family love it. I've been making it at least once a week and it's still all done each time.
Varian77 2 years agoBland as is, had I known I would have found another recipe or adjusted this one
krusert 2 years agoThis recipe is great! I've made it twice now and loved it both times, thanks for posting!
Mollymcferren 2 years agoThis is a great jumping off point for mushroom soup! I added a couple small diced red potatoes because I didn't have a full pound of mushrooms. I also added a little onion and minced garlic. I blended about 3/4 of the soup before adding milk. Since I didn't have cream I used Vitamin D milk and a little sour cream. We loved it. Thank you!
vzwdanielle 2 years agohow much sherry? will rate higher
tonydonegal 2 years ago10 out of 10 excellent soup just after making it.
Shelley6969 2 years agoVery yummy ! Easy to make !
Islebabe520 2 years agoBest, easy homemade mushroom soup.