Great American Potato Salad

Try this Great American Potato Salad recipe, or contribute your own. "Lunch" and "Creamy" are two of the tags cooks chose for Great American Potato Salad.

(4.1, 26) 77% would make again

1926 people marked it a Favorite, 898 people marked it a Try Soon

Yield: 8 Ready in 45 minutes

Cuisine: American   Main Ingredient: Potatoes

Add My Review
Makes a delicious potato salad. I substituted the dill relish with sweet relish and used Miracle Whip. Everybody loved it. Thanks! You guys are awesome!
Professor48 , 10 months ago
Great base as said before, need stronger flavoring.
cwoitas26 , 1 years ago
Its a great base to start out with ^.^ i tweeked it to my own liking; adding some mustard, a couple more eggs and bacon
newbie4 , 1 years ago
britishfairellc , 1 years ago
I liked the look of this recipe until I realised that it was made from already made products that are not available here in the uk. Helmans mayo is fine but do I add fresh dill instead of a dill realish? I wonder if this would be the same if everything in it was fresh rather than processed?
jojutsum , 1 years ago
Great potato salad! I left out relish, and used Helmann's Real Mayo. Yummm!
jasmine314 , 2 years ago
AschleyGarrett , 2 years ago
jasmine314 , 2 years ago
jarkrt , 2 years ago
This is a great recipe! I used an extra egg, along with more seasoning (cayenne pepper, paprika) and a lot more mustard and relish. It turned out wonderfully!
IrrationalBakedGoods , 2 years ago
Ewww on the toxic mayo! I used expeller pressed mayo. Pretty good with healthy mayo.
Helenlampinen , 2 years ago
Awesome recipe. I used chives instead of onions and it was perfect
Crystaldahl , 2 years ago
Measurements were definitely off for me as well. And I felt the seasoning was rather bland. I tweaked the recipe however to my liking.
AmandaBee0 , 2 years ago
Really average potato salad. Definitely too light on the potatoes. Two stars instead of three for listing big brand names. Did Kraft pay you to do that? Lol, come on...
coloryouin , 2 years ago
This is the best potato salad I have tasted, and I am not usually a fan. Great recipe, thanks!
kerribridges , 3 years ago
We all agreed, this recipe is a keeper. Simple ingredients, great results. Thanks
Sgutierr , 3 years ago
this was great.although i think it needs more seasoning to me... i am deff keeping this recipe thanks!!
heinrich54 , 3 years ago
Great flavor! Serving at a large party today-can't wait! I also substituted dill pickles and juice for the relish.
wendyl48 , 3 years ago
A very reliable classic recipe! I don't tend to have relish around so I just chop up some dill pickles as well as adding a splash of pickle juice, gives it a great tangy flavour!
Amgreen , 3 years ago
I just made this for my family b.b.q, they loved it! I left out a couple ingredients (because I didn't have the relish and didn't put eggs because I was also making a seperate egg salad) but it was still delicious,thank you for the recipe (^__^) I'll definately make this again
Alexx37 , 3 years ago
Add unlimited recipes. Organize in custom folders. Find recipes for your diet. Try BigOven Pro Free