Ready in 2 hours
Doesn't taste like diet food! Cooling, tasty and fewer cals than other Key Lime contenders. I have made this over and over, as it is always popular.
"The texture was so silky, I loved it. I made my own pie crust as to cut down the calories, I got each of the 8 slices down to 118 calories but using splenda and reduced fat graham crackers. This was absolutely delicious and I will be making often!"- pineapplebutter
1,408 people want to try | 2,181 have favorited
1. Carefully brush graham cracker crust with egg white (gently, so crust doesnt crack). Bake in 375 degree oven for 5 min. Remove, let cool.
2. In the meantime, in a large heat-resistant bowl, dissolve gelatin in boiling water.
3. Add fresh lime juice and lime zest to gelatin mixture.
4. With wire whisk, stir in yogurt
5. With wooden spoon, fold in whipped topping.
6. Transfer mixture to prepared, cooled crust. Refrigerate overnight, or at least 2 hours.
(Use the crust's plastic cover, flipped over so it makes a dome, as the lid, to keep pie fresh while chilling. Lid also makes this pie easy to transport to a gathering.)
7. Slice and serve into 8 pieces: garnished with thin lime slice, if desired.
Guest, you can Add a link to another recipe! What would you serve with this?
BigOven makes mealtime easy!
You may also enjoy:
charlesangerstein 3 months agoThis is one of the most disgusting things I've ever put in my mouth.
scadata 6 months agoEasy and fun to make. It's very delicious!
mikeyanna 7 months agoJust made this today and it was fantastic! Everyone loved it. I bought the cool whip and it was good, but I think next time I'm going to buy heavy whipping cream and use truvia to make my own sugar free whipped cream.
ohhamsterbaby 7 months agoThis pie is so good and so simple to make. I made an orange one instead of key lime, and it was delicious!
gabeshappymom 8 months ago
Avery316 9 months agoAwesome this tastes delicious must try pie!
bmshipley 10 months ago
blanton3315 10 months ago
kat85seidl 1 year ago
NicholeAnn99 1 year agoI am 13 and I just got done making this pie it is setting we all tried the filling and it was delicious and such an easy recipe
katherinepadilla 1 year ago
katherinepadilla 1 year agoDeliciouse...
txbrowneyes99 1 year agoTastegreat
culinaryart 1 year agoThis was a success when it comes to taste, but somehow the pie did not hold together. It was a real mess. I made it the night before and put it in the fridge overnight and still no result. It brought laughters and everyone really loved the taste of it. I will definitely give it another try.
dawnbrehm 1 year agoYum! Taste great and easy to make!
erikawatkinsechavarria 1 year agoThis was a hit at home and at work. Will try again with strawberry jello and yogurt or cherry or peach......the possibilities are endless !
raeannamiller 1 year agoI love it.! It tastes like my grandmothers key lime pie.! No diffrence.!
pookie7474 1 year agoVery delicious!! Light & tangy, just perfect! Added a bit extra lime zest & juice. Will be a regular in my house. Thanks for sharing!
engridpitts 1 year agoLight, tasty and delicious! My husband's favorite!
Shescrafty 2 years agoYummy! I prefer this to regular key lime pie. It's lighter and obviously less calories. My kids and husband love it to. I followed the recipe as it's written, but might add a little more lime juice next time for extra tart!