Key Lime Pie (Weight Watchers) 3 pts per slice

Doesn't taste like diet food! Cooling, tasty and fewer cals than other Key Lime contenders. I have made this over and over, as it is always popular.

(4.4, 42) 83% would make again

2937 people marked it a Favorite, 2086 people marked it a Try

Yield: 8 Servings Ready in 2 hours

Cuisine: American   Main Ingredient: Lime


Add My Review
Yummy! I prefer this to regular key lime pie. It's lighter and obviously less calories. My kids and husband love it to. I followed the recipe as it's written, but might add a little more lime juice next time for extra tart!
Shescrafty , 3 years ago
I have loved this pie since I first tired it. It is fantastic
midnight165 , 3 years ago
This is a good & easy to make recipe. A little too tart for my taste but good.
u_foundwaldo , 3 years ago
If you like Key Lime Pie this is a great way to get rid of the sweet tooth
c_monts , 4 years ago
I don't do sugar free or completely fat free used 1/2 fat whipped topping but it was excellent my 15 year old son made this just following the recipe.
Owenlee1975 , 4 years ago
I have mad this and my husband ate almost a whole pie , That's how good it is,
LadySnow , 4 years ago
THis is so delicious! And you could make it any flavor just change the jello and yogurt flavors!
ginactrez , 5 years ago
This is a pie that diabetics can eat, and i love it. It tastes like the real thing, too.
redneckboy1952 , 5 years ago
We could not get enough, can't wait to make it again. It was fabulous!!!
midnight165 , 5 years ago
this was fabulous
midnight165 , 5 years ago
I love this recipe. Been using it for several years. Shared it with my Mother In Law and now its a favorite of our nieces and nephews too.
justdawn , 5 years ago
The texture was so silky, I loved it. I made my own pie crust as to cut down the calories, I got each of the 8 slices down to 118 calories but using splenda and reduced fat graham crackers. This was absolutely delicious and I will be making often!
pineapplebutter , 5 years ago
I have made this pie numerous times using different types of yogurt to match the jello. I don't bake my crust and there are times I don't use a crust and just put in parfait glasses.
mona1949 , 5 years ago
I love this recipe. My kids love it too. Its healthy and yummy at the same time.
fatchops , 5 years ago
No improvements needed, it was delicious and very refreshing!
coninmi , 6 years ago
NascarRick , 6 years ago
Tasty, but could be a little more tangy - a little too much whipped topping flavor
mom2Josh , 6 years ago
Needs more lime flavor
ww_Jay , 7 years ago
Add unlimited recipes. Organize in custom folders. Find recipes for your diet. Try BigOven Pro Free