Reviews for Peanut Butter Cookies | BigOven

Peanut Butter Cookies

This is the peanut butter cookie my Mom and Grandma used to make. It's still one of my favorite cookies. When these sweet, salty morsels of happiness come out of the oven, they are just as good today as they were when I was a kid. The recipe originally appeared on the Skippy peanut butter label in the early 1950's. It produces cookies that are golden brown with wonderful flavor and a light crispiness that melts in your mouth. Basically, it's everything you would expect a good peanut butter cookie to be.

(4.6, 134) 85% would make again

7503 people marked it a Favorite, 3761 people marked it a Try Soon

Yield: 5 Ready in 45 minutes

Cuisine: American   Main Ingredient: Peanut Butter

Add My Review
Chose the chewier cookie, absolutely amazing!
ResistanceIsFertile , 6 months ago
Great recipe. I added caramel bits to this recipe and it tasted wonderful.
JL503 , 8 months ago
lisazazzarino , 8 months ago
No flavor waste of time and ingredients .
bridgetkolackidonchez , 9 months ago
My husband and I made this yesterday and it was awesome! We substituted the butter with coconut oil 1-to-1 and baked it immediately and they came out super crispy! Everyone loved it!
ChocolimeBeaver , 9 months ago
Perfect, absolutely enjoyed!
Photoree , 10 months ago
Made into cookie bars with butterscotch and white chocolate chips. Very yummy and easy!
FluffyChefDMACC , 10 months ago
Just what I was craving.
scolorado , 10 months ago
So light and airy. Usually I only make them for hubby but I finally found a pb cookie that I'll actually eat.
sandyyoung167 , 11 months ago
easy to make. kids liked tjem with crunchy peanut butter
cat80 , 1 years ago
I love it!!!
kedab98 , 1 years ago
These were delicious! I added Ghirardelli chocolate chips the first time. Came out amazing! This time I used mini peanut butter cups from trader joes... Again amazing! Thanks for this fabulous recipe!
Kimbero911 , 1 years ago
Amazing the cookie dough itself was fabu, the cookies were another story delishous amazing thx
FinnTheCook , 1 years ago
I added 1/2tsp vanilla and 1/2tsp almond extract.
JRapp80 , 1 years ago
Very tasty. Took them in to work and everyone was asking for more.
Tkytam , 1 years ago
Very good and very easy. I only chilled them 30 minutes and they still came out soft and chewy.
Mamaschaef , 1 years ago
The cookies were soft on the inside and crunchy on the outside -Delicious. Thanks for sharing:)
Moochiebacabella , 1 years ago
A bit dry. But yummy!!
RMDye , 1 years ago
Awesome recipe! We made these last night and they were perfect. I added M&M's to half the batch and will be making these again.
Sandi4 , 1 years ago
Sondrasue , 1 years ago
Add unlimited recipes. Organize in custom folders. Find recipes for your diet. Try BigOven Pro Free