Ready in 45 minutes
This recipe is so easy it unbelievable. There are only 3 ingredients.
"I was a little skeptical about this recipe but I had to try them out as I've been an avid baker for years. They were wonderful! As suggested by another reviewer, I added 1 teasp of vanilla, a little less sugar, a pinch of salt and added a chocolate kiss immediately after removing from the oven. This is a great recipe that will now replace my old pb cookie recipe."- dgonzalez3
522 people want to try | 802 have favorited
Preheat oven to 350 degrees.
Combine ingredients in a medium sized mixing bowl. Drop by spoonfuls onto a baking sheet. Place reserved sugar on a plate or waxed paper. Dip a potato masher, the kind with the square holes, into the sugar and then press the spoonfuls of cookie dough with the potato masher. (If you don't have the potato masher, use a fork to make the cross hatch marks.)
Bake cookies for 8-10 minutes. Cool on a wire rack.
Guest, you can Add a link to another recipe! What would you serve with this?
BigOven makes mealtime easy!
You may also enjoy:
lolagrass 1 month agoPerfect kid friendly, ez pb cookies! I like them slightly undercooked because they firm up a bit when thet cool and I loooove them soft and chewy. Allow to cool first, but be sure to store them in an airtight container so they stay soft and delicious!
chuck40 5 months ago
MissyMeMarie 6 months ago
kaylynne83 6 months ago
idydell 6 months agoVery east
kelleyh036107 8 months agoIt was sooooooo awesome
LisaMommy 11 month agoOh my gosh! I just made these! SO good!! I also added some vanilla, a couple shakes of salt & reduced the sugar just by a tablespoon. They are a bit greasy but very easy. I better hide them before I eat them all!!
MissElvis 11 month agoI've made these before....... leave them in the oven a bit longer......they get a nummy crunchy shell. My batter was grainy but the cookies turned out aok they are a perfect holiday treat
rjlopez31 12 months agoThis is a favorite in my family. So easy my 4 year old loves to help (I love that we don't end up with flour in our hair). And so good they don't last long. Actually my 4 year old is a picky eater, but when it comes to this recipe she loves it.
nancymaster 1 year agoI can't imagine that I did anything wrong but these were not good. Grainy and mushy.. they will probably end up in the garbage
melissaoutmanzilcosky 1 year agoI learned this recipe in home ec class and have been making these for years. I don't add anything else to them. My kids love them!!
Farrzoe 1 year agothese were great. i added vanilla extract like a few others, they were a bit sweet so i might use a little less sugar next time.
dgonzalez3 2 years agoI was a little skeptical about this recipe but I had to try them out as I've been an avid baker for years. They were wonderful! As suggested by another reviewer, I added 1 teasp of vanilla, a little less sugar, a pinch of salt and added a chocolate kiss immediately after removing from the oven. This is a great recipe that will now replace my old pb cookie recipe.
Maggieannmerritt 2 years agoI made these cookies and they came out sticky and could not roll them out.
Jennshe 2 years agoI have to admit I had my doubts when I saw this recipe, but I was in the mood the bake and low on ingredients and cash. So figured what the heck. Wow these are great, definitely a good one to keep on hand
DGMom 2 years agoDelicious and so easy will definitely make again
SerenaVictoria 2 years agoThese are the only peanut butter cookies I make. Have been for a while. They are amazing and everyone loves them. I also add white chocolate chips from time to time. So good. Plus you always have these ingredients on hand.
Whitewhitt08 2 years agoBeen using this same recipe for a while, plus a pinch of salt and vanilla, and heard nothing but amazed compliments on it. Started topping with cinnamon after baking for a little flavor twist. Easily my favorite recipe for peanut butter cookies
Mumof278 2 years agoCan't believe they worked yummo
taylorkylee 2 years agoDidnt think they were that great. Maybe I did something wrong. They were just weird.