jerebel ,They aren't exactly chewy, however I got RAVE reviews when I made them. I put some "Ande's" mint chips and "Hershey" kisses on top and I didn't even get one cookie! They ate them all. (Good thing I sneaked a bite of the dough and OH BOY yummy!) I made batch after batch of these cookies over the holidays and I ended up getting 1cookie out of about 60 that I made. Lol I'm definitely making these again.10y
mrsgulley01 ,Very good and easy to make. Topped off cookies with cinnamon and sugar mixture and others with candy sprinkles. Used sour cream instead of milk... The cookies turned out perfectly chewy. I love this recipe.10y
cakeandcookies ,The best sugar cookies ever. I make them all the time. Going to make them this weekend in fact!10y
luckamacm ,These are great and very easy to make. I might add less sugar next time because for me they were way too sweet but the kids LOVED them and said it was their new favourite cookie.10y
cakeandcookies ,Love them! Dairy free buttermilk: mix soy milk with 6 drops lemon juice.let sit for 5 minutes. These cookies are delicious!!!10y
sugarbaby24 ,Great recipe! I've used it twice, and both times I've substituted light sour cream for buttermilk, and it turned out amazing!10y
kejohannes ,Made 5 dozens for Mother's Day for work on Friday. Everyone LOVED them. So I made another 2 dozen for my family on Saturday. Thanks! And thanks for the tip about buttermilk and sour cream!10y
mandiepalmer16 ,Awesome recipe! Will be making some again soon.... like tomorrow! Next time I'll try not to eat so much of the dough11y
resistanceisfertile ,Tasty, chewy cookies! Didn't have buttermilk on hand so I used white vinegar and some milk and let it sit 5 minutes. Works the same.11y
joelle123123 ,Very easy to make. I like a soft cookie so after cooling down store these in a container to moisten them.11y
brittneymeier ,This is one of the best ones ive used!! Though I used sour cream instead of buttermilk, this is a softening secret I learned from my great grandma. Bless her heart. Try it.11y
seanulmighty ,I followed the recipe and I must have a different definition of sugar cookie cause these weren't very sweet and tasted like a butter cookie11y