Ready in 1 hour
These great cookies have a brownie type taste with a gooey caramel chocolatey center from the Rolos.
"A friend gave us this recipe, and it is one of the best cookies we've ever had. They are great right out of the oven warm and fresh, but they also taste incredible the next day etc... They are a little labor intensive (have to unwrap each rolo and roll them in batter etc...) but they are so worth it!"- melarky
1,343 people want to try | 1,752 have favorited
Top-ranked recipe named "Brownie Like Rolo Cookies"
Mix sugars, baking cocoa, margarine, vanilla, and eggs. Once it's all mixed add the flour and the soda. Refrigerate dough for 30 minutes. Roll dough around Rolo (should be about the size of a ping pong ball) and roll in sugar (extra white sugar, not from main ingredients). Place on ungreased cookie sheet and bake at 375 for 7-10 mins. You can usually tell when they are done when the tops are starting to crack.
BigOven makes mealtime easy!
You may also enjoy:
Golizliz 1 month agoI was excited to try this, but didn't work out for me. I used Hershey's cocoa powder (which is prob why it tasted bland?) and followed directions to a tee. No one in the fam seemed to have liked it...except for biting into the caramel part of the cookie
melarky 2 months agoIt's baking soda
Sandi77 2 months agoI have a question regarding the soda. Is it soda water or baking soda? If can anyone help me out, I'd appreciate it!!
Jenwren 2 months agoTook these to a Christmas cookie exchange! They were a hit.
dbussen001 2 months ago
McLellanCM 3 months agoSoooo good, especially fresh. Serve a few with a scoop of vanilla ice cream for a Pizookie like dessert
Jmavro 7 months agoI made these for a BBQ, everyone loved them, adults and kiddos! Definitely a hit!
daniel95 11 month agoVery good and my family wouldn't stop eating them
Sherryje 1 year agoAmazing and highly addictive I only needed just over 2 cups of flour tho but they were fantastic and they stayed soft for days
courtneyharp78657 1 year agoThese cookies are amazing and the actual name of them is the million dollar cookies
countrymommak22 1 year agoMy families and my favorite cookies :D
Nikjamrcm 1 year agoThese are yummy however the dough was super sticky and the rolos melted out the bottom of the cookies and stuck to the cookie sheet. I am going to try with more flour next time to see if it works better.
christinebakke 1 year ago
jennijen 1 year agoThese are amazing and very easy to make. They were a huge hit at a family party.
firstigloochick 1 year agoI made these and my husband said that they were the best cookies he had ever eaten in his entire life! I defiantly recommend baking them on parchment paper.
mommyx307 1 year agoIncredibly delicious and SUPER easy! Must try!
LoveMyHusband29 1 year agoThese taste great! I am not fond of rolling the cookies in sugar so I think next time I will skip that step. Otherwise these are awesome, especially fresh out of the oven!
katylaclair 1 year agoMaking these right now, I just tried one out of the first batch, and oh my goodness!! These are amazing!
Tashafinnamore 2 years agoAbsolutely delicious. Everyone should try these.
Hailsblue 2 years agoI haven't actually made these but it says that you have to have 48 rolos. I'm just gonna use a couple of blocks of rolos to save time instead of getting a dozen small packets of rolos that only have like seven in them