Ready in 1 hour
Try this Peanut Butter Frosting recipe, or contribute your own. "Frostings" and "Cakes" are two of the tags cooks chose for Peanut Butter Frosting.
"This was great! I used planters natural creamy peanut butter. My husband loved it, I put it on Choc cupcakes, would make again! I will say, if you are not a big fan of peanut butter, this recipie is not for you, this has serious peanut taste! :-) "- amlmckenzie1
663 people want to try | 1,150 have favorited
In a large bowl with mixer at medium speed, beat peanut butter and butter until light and fluffy. Gradually, beat in sugar, alternately, with milk until frosting is a good spreading consistency. Beat in vanilla extract. Makes enough frosting to frost one 13 x 9 x 2" cake. Submitted By SAM WARING
Guest, you can Add a link to another recipe! What would you serve with this?
BigOven makes mealtime easy!
You may also enjoy:
carlsonrodriguez 10 months agoWaaaaaaaay to sweet for my diabetic family members.
jackfischer12 1 year ago
Highvoltagelineman 1 year agoVery good,made chocolate cupcakes with this icing everyone loved them. People asked for the recipe. Definitely will make again
amlmckenzie1 1 year agoThis was great! I used planters natural creamy peanut butter. My husband loved it, I put it on Choc cupcakes, would make again! I will say, if you are not a big fan of peanut butter, this recipie is not for you, this has serious peanut taste! :-)
trishmordacq 1 year agoI just made this to go on top of the worlds chocolatiest brownies (a recipe on here) WOW these are good together.
moomasters 1 year agoMy husband loves peanut butter, so I made a peanut butter/chocolate checkered cake & used this frosting recipe. It was a 4 layered cake, so I ended up having to double the recipe. Oh. My. Goodness. Is this recipe ever delicious?!? It was so light and fluffy and not too sweet! Will DEFINITELY use this recipe again!
anierenberg1 2 years agoeveryone loved these cupcakes!! my brother who is not into sweets has three himself which is saying a lot!!! now he wants me to make them for his birthday!!!
Bekalah36 2 years agoThis is really good! I've made it a few times now.
Muggs314 2 years agoAmazing! Can't be beat - best icing ever! Light, creamy, fluffy!
Tracyd22 2 years agoVery good, even better the next day
lilreeldancer 2 years agodelicious, rich and not too sweet.
Amy23 2 years agoEasy and tasty. Turned out very creamy. Would highly recommend with brownies.
JoLuMama99 2 years agoLOVE it!!! I didnt have quite a full tsp of vanilla left but it was a little more than half and it is wonderful! I tried it before adding the vanilla and it was still great!'
Crankeeyankee 2 years agoFabulous! Light, fluffy and delicious. I took another reviewers advice and cut the vanilla to 1/2 tsp. Perfect. Very easy to make and recipe made enough to frost a 9 X 13 cake.
Butterflyscorpian 2 years agoVery very good. Perfect amount of peanut butter. Icing very fluffy. Will stick with this recipe!
Gabbey50 3 years agoThis was really really amazing I will continue to use this recipe :) I love the fluffy texture and it has the perfect amount of pb. But I would recommend only a 1/2 ts of vanilla :)
amandakrylo 4 years agoThe taste an texture is awsome. I will be using this frosting a lot! Great on chocolate cake!