Ready in 1h
Try this Old-Fashioned Banana Cream Pie recipe, or contribute your own.
Combine flour, sugar, salt and eggs in a medium saucepan. Beat with hand beater or wire whip until well mixed. Add milk gradually and continue beating until smooth. Cook over medium heat until mixture thickens, stirring constantly. Remove from heat. Stir butter and 1 tsp. vanilla into hot mixture. Place in refrigerator. Slice bananas into cooked pie shell. Remove custard from refrigerator and spoon over bananas. Whip whipping cream until soft peaks form. Gradually add sugar and whip until stiff. Fold in remaining vanilla. Spread over pie, sealing edges. Refrigerate and serve very cold. Posted by: Debbie Carlson (D.CARLSON - GEnie)
jlweide 2y agoDelicious! The recipe is a little confusing. The 1 1/2 c. sugar goes in the custard and the 1 T. sugar goes in the whipping cream.
Jay-marie820 2y agoMy favorite recipe by far my family loves it whenever I make them this pie it's always requested around the holidays :)
Sparksteam 2y agoI can't tell you how much I love this recipe. The first time I made it I messed up on the custard I didn't even know what custard was at the time so it was a little liquidy. After I made it a second and third time I pretty much perfected it. I've given it to neighbors friends and family and every single one of them gave me amazing reviews even my vegetarian friends are obsessed about it. Thank you for such a great recipe I'll tell you what it is way better warm to my husband doesn't like pies or sweets at all and he loves it
Zjm27 3y agoI made it for my Birthday and it was amazing!!!
kdkohut 3y agoVery skeptical at first but it came out amazing!!!!! It was gone within 24 hours! Delicious! Thank you!
Jibby321 3y agoGood recipe but instructions are very confusing - I accidentally mixed up the sugar amounts in the custard/topping because it didn't say which was for which :( I had to make the pie twice to get it right but it was a hit!
Sparksteam 3y agoMakes about three 9 inch pies
10yearoldcook 3y agoAwesome!!! So simple and it taste great :)
11yearoldcook 4y agoGreat!!! I mixed bananas in to custard and then put into pie shell
SabinaMK 4y agoDelicious! It was a big hit at my house!