Southern Style Buttermilk Pie (makes 2 Pies)

Southern Style Buttermilk Pie (makes 2 Pies)

Ready in 1 hour
4.7 avg, 10 review(s) 90% would make again

Top-ranked recipe named "Southern Style Buttermilk Pie (makes 2 Pies)"

Share it:

Old southern style recipe,Not for the person who's watching there calories. This pie is sweet,rich and and has a custard style texture. Exellent served hot or cold !!! This pie is one of my all time favorites. This recipe is simple to make and your guest's will LOVE IT !!!!

"LOVED IT! Our oven was on the fritz so I had to make them individually in my toaster/convection oven. Worked wonderfully and everyone loved it! Buttermilk Pie is one of our favorites and this recipe was delicious! :)"

- tn_renee_1965

Ingredients

Are you making this? 
-- MIX --
7 lrg Eggs
1 teaspoon Salt
1 1/2 teaspoons Pure vanilla extract
-- ADD --
3 1/2 cups White Sugar; Blend
3/4 cup Flour; Blend
1 cup Buttermilk; Blend
2/3 cup Melted Margarine; Not too hot/Blend
2 Deep Dish Pie Shells

Original recipe makes 8

Slices  

Preparation

Mix all ingredients well and pour into 2 (two) unbaked pie shells.Bake for 45 minutes to 1 hour at 325? degree oven. If a puddle of butter forms in the middle of the pie, pour off and return to the oven. Test with tooth pick to make sure pie is done. (tooth pick will come out clean when pie is done.

Serve warm or cold,garnish with whipped cream and or a lemon wedge

Credits

Added on Award Medal
Verified by stevemur

If you have never had a true Southern dessert before this one is simple to make & tastes fantastic photo by HarleyRidingChef HarleyRidingChef

photo by CatrinaTX CatrinaTX

Calories Per Serving: 1144 Get detailed nutrition information, including line-by-line nutrition insights?  Try BigOven Pro for Free for 14 days!

Date My private notes
Add your own private notes with BigOven Pro!

Recipe Links

Link in another recipe. What would you serve with this?

Reviews for Southern Style Buttermilk Pie (makes 2 Pies)

I'd rate it:


sign in to add your comment

Learn more

Buttermilk Vitamin B-2

Tags


Reviews

Add yours!

This pie is so divine you will be glad it makes 2! It makes the house smell amazing and none of my pie night guests could pass it up.
btmarsh 4 months ago
I halfed the recipe. Very good, a bit eggy tasting. Was a hit.
mommavalerie 1 year ago
cmv013 1 year ago
YUMMY!!!
Smile5309 2 years ago
Awesome! Taste like old time Buttermilk pie! Was hit at the Thanksgiving table
Ihallmark 2 years ago
Awesome! Halved the recipe and forgot to half the salt (oops!!), but still turned out fabulously!! Added picture of my completed pie.
CatrinaTX 2 years ago
LOVED IT! Our oven was on the fritz so I had to make them individually in my toaster/convection oven. Worked wonderfully and everyone loved it! Buttermilk Pie is one of our favorites and this recipe was delicious! :)
tn_renee_1965 2 years ago
Very simple & delicious!! I made these for Thanksgiving & no one ate the pumpkin pie!! Very good with some whipped cream on top.
Cinethia 4 years ago
easy to make Rates 5 stars
HarleyRidingChef 6 years ago
[I posted this recipe.]
HarleyRidingChef 6 years ago
Add unlimited recipes. Organize in custom folders. Find recipes for your diet. Try BigOven Pro Free