jusiswife ,Love this recipe but over the years I can't eat such sweet things so I added 4 ozs sour cream to the recipe!11y
kickamom ,This is great! So easy and the measurements were perfect. I even used light vanilla Silk in place of the milk and it tasted awesome!12y
aprilcanlearntocook ,Love it! Yes, it is very sweet and I'm so glad! Most of the other buttercream frosting recipes I tried were not and thus, very bland to me. When I looked at the reviews for this recipe and saw people complaining about it being too sweet I knew I had to try it. Icing is meant to be sweet! And this one fits the bill! I did add a little extra milk to make it more spreadable but other than that it's perfect.12y
rheiss591 ,It wasn't good. Its way too sweet, and there is too much vanilla making it have a weird flavor.12y
padsy ,Delicious! While extremely sweet I found that adding a bitter cocoa helped lessen it and I ended up with a really luscious chocolate frosting. Super awesome for a quick cake topping in a pinch!12y
jacquelinewood ,Way too sweet! I put in more milk and added flour to try to fix it but it was still too sweet.12y
whitney036 ,It was okay... Too sweet for my liking & didn't care much for the taste that the vanilla gave it...12y
buliebaker17 ,This is now my go to icing. Found this recipe some time ago and have been using it ever since. It gets tons of compliments every time. Thank you so much for posting it!12y
stephanie1997 ,I enjoyed this.definitely easy to work with and I added food coloring as well. Will use again12y
saintly ,How many cups is a pound of icing?? We buy ours in bags here in Vancouver, BC Canada.14y
melarky ,It was good. I put red food coloring in it and used it on a chocolate cake. I'd use it again, it was a good generic frosting recipe.14y