For the Meatballs: combine bread and buttermilk in small bowl, mashing occasionally with a fork, until smooth paste forms, about 10 minutes. Mix all meatball ingredients, including bread mixture and pepper to taste in medium bowl. Lightly form 3 tablespoons of mixture into 1 1/2 inch round meatballs, repeat with remaining mixture to form approximately 14 meatballs. (Compacting them can make the meatballs dense and hard. Can be placed on a large plate, covered loosely with plastic wrap, and refrigerated for several house.) Heat 1/4 inch vegetable oil over medium high heat in 10 or 11 inch saute pan. When edge of meatball is dipped in the oil sizzles, add meatballs in a single layer. Fry, turning several times, until nicely browned on all sides, about 10 minutes, regulating heat as needed to keep oil sizzling but not smoking. Transfer browned meatballs to paper towel lined plate; set aside. Repeat, if necessary with remaining meatballs. For the Sauce: Discard the oil in the pan leaving behind any browned bits. Add olive oil along with garlic, saute, scraping up any browned bits. just until garlic is golden, about 30 seconds. Add tomatoes, bring to boil, and simmer gently until sauce thickens, about 10 minutes. Stir in basil; add salt and pepper to taste. Add meatballs and simmer, turning them occasionally, until heated through, about 5 minutes. Keep warm over low flame. Serve over your choice of pasta. Recipe by: Jan/Feb 1998 issue Posted to FOODWINE Digest by Terry Pogue <tpogue@IDSONLINE.COM> on Dec 17, 1997
Reviews
☆☆☆☆☆
I made this tonight -- it was excellent.... Great recipe! Thank you to whomever posted it. I didn't have any problems at all with the meatballs and followed the recipe exactly. Not sure what the problem was with the previous poster who complained about them. They were perfect. The only difference I made was to refrigerate them for about 30 minutes while I got ready to cook. I served with cheesy garlic bread and a salad. I did submit a picture, but my camera is broken, so apologies for the bad photo quality. This was delicious and is definitely going into my favorites!
catgurrl
Wow, are you really that generous MaxCaviar, or did we get it wrong? 4 stars for a recipe that you wouldn't make again?
stevemur
☆☆☆☆
I am usually happy with most all Cook Illustrated recipes. This one didn't work so hot though. The meatballs just would not retain their shape, ending up looking more like meatcubes from resting on a flat surface. No problems with the flavor, but I have had better.
Find any recipe, add your own, make grocery lists easily from recipes. Enter any 3 ingredients and BigOven will tell you what you can make. It's free! (4.5/5 stars)