Chocolate Peanut Butter Squares

This is one of my childhood favorites. A layer of creamy sweet peanut butter topped with a layer of chocolate, remniscent of Reese's peanut butter cups. These squares are quick and simple to make, and are so yummy and addictive! They also freeze well.

(4.6, 194) 81% would make again
Yield: 24 Servings

Cuisine: American-South   Main Ingredient: Peanut Butter


Add My Review
Will make again but with milk chocolate.
patyandjoey , 2y ago

cookida , 2y ago

I made this last week and i got millions of appreciations from my friends. Thanks!
randurini , 2y ago

Great dessert, I used chunky peanut butter and I think its better than the creamy.
logan_mcdonald , 2y ago

So good. Just like a peanut butter cup and so easy to make.
sonjbak , 2y ago

Quick and easy recipe. My family liked it a lot.
trishaann33 , 3y ago

They are so easy and good
lowtristen11 , 3y ago

These are fantastic! Tastes just like a Reece's peanut butter cup and they are so quick and easy to make. They freeze wonderfully and actually taste better frozen in my opinion. Will definitely be making again and again :)
peanut53 , 3y ago

Phri freakin nominal
clynn1106 , 3y ago

Love this
miller241 , 3y ago

Amazing result with so little effort! I wanted to make something new with what I had on hand and these were perfect! Dough is very stiff and I did lightly grease my hands to make it easier to work with. Taste? OMG was everyones comment! Keep posting..your stuff is great! Thanks
cyag , 3y ago

carsue , 3y ago

Absolutely delicious and very easy to make. They actually taste just like Reece's. I suggest freezing the peanut butter layer while you melt the chocolate, then pouring on the chocolate and freezing for 10 minutes. One the chocolate starts to solidify but is still soft, cut into squares. This helps cut perfect lines once it's completely solid.
chellybeans , 3y ago

rejakshi , 3y ago

Back when I was in school they called them Magic Squares. Everyone loved when these were on the menu. Thank you for reminding me of a wonderful, nostalgic dessert.
crazycouponlady4 , 3y ago

olivchel , 3y ago

Very simple and tastes great.
cbales03 , 3y ago

Must've done something wrong because I couldn't get the mixture to stay in the pan. Too sticky. They taste good though.
loiamve , 3y ago

This is a treat for the gods ....omg thanks sgrishka for putting this up. I also make them into popcycles sooooo awesome
heyitskat , 3y ago

Tastes just like a Reese to me and my wife. Definitely going to make again.
mrmoonie , 3y ago

    Add unlimited recipes. Remove ads. Custom folders. Find recipes for your diet. Try BigOven Pro Free