Butterfinger Cake

This butterfinger cake recipe is the best cake ever, I make it all the time.

(4.5, 191) 83% would make again

8897 people marked it a Favorite, 5458 people marked it a Try Soon

Yield: 12 Servings Ready in 45 minutes

Cuisine: American   Main Ingredient: Cake

Add My Review
kusumsangwan , 1 years ago
Seriously. If you are looking for nut-free recipes, 99% of the time someone in your family has a peanut allergy. This recipe could kill them. Butterfingers are not nut-free. They are made with peanuts. Don't get into the semantics of peanuts versus nuts. Not with people's lives at stake.
kilikina778 , 1 years ago
Oh. As for those complaining that this is in the "nut free" section? Peanuts are not, in fact, nuts. Research, people, research!
SanguinePony , 1 years ago
Tracy26 , 1 years ago
maffu , 1 years ago
twisted1331 , 1 years ago
I like this cake but prefer it without the chocolate and caramel. Nice and easy!
marcieschlecht , 1 years ago
Made first time today I only used half can milk and also whipped in some Butterfingers in the cool whip. It was very good. Not to over like I thought it would be. :-)
heatherhendrickson , 1 years ago
One word...naughty (but delicious)!
polsleybarnes , 1 years ago
ALostMidget , 1 years ago
Wow! This may be my new "go to" dessert! Super easy !
Ssuitepea , 1 years ago
Warning!!!!! Butterfingers contain roasted peanuts!!!!! This recipe is not peanut free!!!!!
Sampson700 , 1 years ago
katiemeyers2012 , 1 years ago
Very rich cake but delicious. We added a layer of shreded coconut below the cool whip and topped with a little toasted coconut. Adds a nice flavor.
santiagomurtagh , 1 years ago
This cake was very good. Used chocolate cake instead. It was VERY sweet so next time I wont use but a little of the condensed milk. Overall, I was very satisfied and can't wait to make it again.
augustdaniellebice , 1 years ago
bittersweetness , 1 years ago
alex209 , 1 years ago
misty13 , 1 years ago
sarahbaker2 , 1 years ago
Its amazing
terrbearfraise , 1 years ago
Add unlimited recipes. Organize in custom folders. Find recipes for your diet. Try BigOven Pro Free