Butterfinger Cake

This butterfinger cake recipe is the best cake ever, I make it all the time.

(4.5, 194) 84% would make again

9002 people marked it a Favorite, 5508 people marked it a Try

Yield: 12 Servings Ready in 45 minutes

Cuisine: American   Main Ingredient: Cake


Add My Review
Delicious!!! Made it for friends and they loved it. I used evaporated milk instead of sweetened condensed milk by mistake but it still turned out tasty and moist. I also only used 2 candy bars since I didn't want it to be overly sweet/crunchy. Will definitely make this again!!
mandana , 1 years ago
This cake is delicious! It's extremely sweet but I've still made it a few times. The family loves it!
1Chefarmiller , 1 years ago
Those that have nut allergies many times have a peanut allergy too. This is not always the case, but err on the side of caution by putting the fact that in contains nuts in the notes section. The life you save may be that of a child whose parent did not now Butterfingers contains nuts. Don't mean to be preachy, but not everyone have common sense these days.
boofortner , 1 years ago
kusumsangwan , 1 years ago
Seriously. If you are looking for nut-free recipes, 99% of the time someone in your family has a peanut allergy. This recipe could kill them. Butterfingers are not nut-free. They are made with peanuts. Don't get into the semantics of peanuts versus nuts. Not with people's lives at stake.
kilikina778 , 1 years ago
Oh. As for those complaining that this is in the "nut free" section? Peanuts are not, in fact, nuts. Research, people, research!
SanguinePony , 1 years ago
Tracy26 , 1 years ago
maffu , 1 years ago
twisted1331 , 2 years ago
I like this cake but prefer it without the chocolate and caramel. Nice and easy!
marcieschlecht , 2 years ago
Made first time today I only used half can milk and also whipped in some Butterfingers in the cool whip. It was very good. Not to over like I thought it would be. :-)
heatherhendrickson , 2 years ago
One word...naughty (but delicious)!
polsleybarnes , 2 years ago
ALostMidget , 2 years ago
Wow! This may be my new "go to" dessert! Super easy !
Ssuitepea , 2 years ago
Warning!!!!! Butterfingers contain roasted peanuts!!!!! This recipe is not peanut free!!!!!
Sampson700 , 2 years ago
katiemeyers2012 , 2 years ago
Very rich cake but delicious. We added a layer of shreded coconut below the cool whip and topped with a little toasted coconut. Adds a nice flavor.
santiagomurtagh , 2 years ago
This cake was very good. Used chocolate cake instead. It was VERY sweet so next time I wont use but a little of the condensed milk. Overall, I was very satisfied and can't wait to make it again.
augustdaniellebice , 2 years ago
bittersweetness , 2 years ago
alex209 , 2 years ago
Add unlimited recipes. Organize in custom folders. Find recipes for your diet. Try BigOven Pro Free