Ready in 1 hour
These are a really great treat! You can use any chocolate frosting you like but the Hersheys bars make great frosting!
"Those are magnificent cookies! Time consuming, but worth it! I added toasted and salted pecan pieces on top of the Hershey bar."- ggilman59
705 people want to try | 1,078 have favorited
Guest, you can Add a link to another recipe! What would you serve with this?
BigOven makes mealtime easy!
You may also enjoy:
hgoodwin1976 4 months agoThese are amazing!!!
Mythgarr 10 months ago
Audreyjones25 11 month agoSuper easy and delicious! My husband loves rolos
Mccaslin1 1 year agoVery rich, and very good! We mixed some dark chocolate chips into the top 'frosting'. Very good!
Gravis 1 year agoNot sure I get it. How many rolos are in a pack, not 40 so I'm assuming you need more than 1 pack...
cjvigg 1 year agoFirst time making these last night. I followed the recipe exactly and did encounter two problems. The dough was tough to mix by hand and by mixer. It seemed a little dry and had A LOT of those dry clumps in it which made rolling into a ball shape difficult because it wouldn't stick together. I had to kinda pick them out if I could. The recipe also didn't say how much dough to use per ball. I used roughly a tablespoon, maybe on the generous side. 2 boxes of cake mix, with 4 jumbo eggs, at a tablespoon per ball, made 42 cookies. One bag of Rolos is enough for this recipe but I'd recommend using 2 jumbo packs of Hershey's bars with pieces to each cookie. Once the chocolate melts and cookies cool completely, the chocolate hardens so you can stack them in an air tight container. A good trick is to put a piece of bread in the air tight container to prevent the cookies from going stale. The bread will go stale and hard while the cookies stay soft.
amandabroughton 1 year agoVery yummy!! Everyone loved them!!!!
Hemein56 1 year ago
davidastewart80 1 year ago
SueShank 1 year agoThese cookies are so good you are garunteed to make them again. Especially if your a chocolate lover!
ggilman59 1 year agoThose are magnificent cookies! Time consuming, but worth it! I added toasted and salted pecan pieces on top of the Hershey bar.
Imadeit 1 year agoTook to a cookie exchange- love these!
Burt4686 1 year agoI thought they were to sweet for my taste(Husband agreed). I used the Hershey frosting and sprinkles on top.
sarac707 1 year agoIt's great.I love rolos too.
yoischic23 1 year agoThanks for sharing this recipe!
Celticviperv 1 year ago
hippolani 2 years agoAddicting!!
ErinCavana 2 years agoMade these for my husband. He loved them. Great alternative to the average chocolate cookie.
Saimasisu 2 years agoThese cookies are amazing. I made 24 dozen cookies for my niece's wedding, and these were the favorites.
pinkmama22 2 years agoThese are super yummy!!! By far the best cookies I have ever made!